Search P-Shock

Reuters sensationalizes Ahmadinejad quote

posted 2007.06.03 Sunday

Matt Drudge blares "COUNTDOWN TO ISRAEL'S END" with a picture of Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad.  The Reuters story to which Drudge links is headlined "Iran president sees 'countdown' to Israel's end".  So, Ahmadinejad is threatening Israel with nukes, right?  Nope.  Allow me to fisk the first four paragraphs of the Reuters piece:

TEHRAN (Reuters) - Iran's president said on Sunday the Lebanese and the Palestinians had pressed a "countdown button" to bring an end to Israel.

Wrong.  He said -- according to the third paragraph in this very article! -- that such a button had been pushed for the destruction of the "Zionist regime".  I would uncontroversially submit that the destruction of a regime -- call it "regime change", if you like -- is not the same as the end of the country it governs.

President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, who triggered outrage in the West two years ago when he said Israel should be "wiped off the map", has often referred to the destruction of the Jewish state but says Iran is not a threat.

The anonymous Reuters reporter (possibly some sort of Iran expert?) may be unfamiliar with the months-old essay in which Arash Norouzi argues that the "wiped off the map" line was a dangerous misreporting of an irresponsible mistranslation, i.e., that Ahmadinejad never said that either.  (Part of the confusion then was also the distinction between a regime and a country.)

"With God's help, the countdown button for the destruction of the Zionist regime has been pushed by the hands of the children of Lebanon and Palestine," Ahmadinejad said in a speech.

"By God's will, we will witness the destruction of this regime in the near future," he said.  He did not elaborate.

How hard would it be to grab a George W. Bush quote out of context, ominously to append that "he did not elaborate", and endlessly to repeat it to a foreign mass audience, thus "proving" that Bush is some sort of evil monster?  (Wait, don't answer that.)  So I have to ask:  Why is this "news" about Ahmadinejad being tidily repackaged and pumped out to Americans?

AddThis Social Bookmark Button




1. apm left...
2007.06.04 Monday 10:58 pm

Drudge is always happy to hype the latest jump in the Rapture Index. Save me Jebus!


2. claire left...
2007.06.11 Monday 1:09 am

totes totes totes. is it august yet?


3. haji left...
2007.07.02 Monday 7:42 pm

Well, he either never heard of the essay, or he did, and realized that MohammadMossadegh.com (a site fully committed to preventing war between the West and Iran) was hardly the most objective source from which to seek impartial reporting.

But if you want to mine Iranian sites for interpretation of what Ahmadinejad said or meant, what better source than the good Iranian President's own site?

I quote: " his firm belief that the new wave of confrontations generated in Palestine and the growing turmoil in the Islamic world would in no time wipe Israel away."

As can be seen by glancing at wikipedia, the idiom "wipe off the map" doesn't exist in Farsi, but the interpretation of his words by his own employees is "wipe Israel away" -- about as close as it can get.

But who cares? The fact is, the man has made little attempt to hide his intentions and desire: that the Jews of Israel be killed, evicted from their land or subjugated under a Muslim majority 'democratic' regime, one that will surely reign there as it has started to in Gaza. With terror.

We are not talking about the type of police state the left claims rules in the US, but a true state of terror -- replete with torture, beheadings and cold murder. And that has all fallen on their own Palistinian, Muslim brethren. What cruel fate would await the infidel Jews of Jerusalem -- those who are the offspring of Apes and Pigs -- those for whom even the trees and rocks have nothing but curses and malice (at least, according to the holy Muslim scriptures)

Have you taken into consideration that the man might actually be a cruel and terrible ruler?